stolen drops in a sunscorched place
August 19th, 2008i wrote this back in february, after visiting a refugee settlement in a mining area near jodhpur.
—————
one hundred million breathtaking heartbreaking suffocating liberating invigorating exhausting captivating terrifying things. india. this is india embedding itself in my consciousness.
quickening steps along sunseared dust. jagged hunks of creamy pink sandstone and twisted bits of tiny scorched roots. the merciful rustle of a lukewarm breeze, the unnervingly human cry of a distant goat. grateful for the breathing of my billowing red and white cotton punjabi suit, the synthetic red scarf trailing behind the carefully placed steps of my camel leather sandals. scowling into the screaming sun, the tiny valley between my eyebrows deepening against the harshest of lights, reflected off the yellowbrown sand and soft pink stone all around. the faces of three sunblackened most somber of men greeting us at the end of the dusty road.
we have arrived at bheel basti refugee settlement on the fringes of the thar desert, several kilometers outside of jodhpur. in periodic surges since the first india-pakistan war in 1965, some 200,000 hindus from pakistan’s sindh province are estimated to have fled from religious persecution across the border to india. before partition in 1947, many of these were poor, low-caste agricultural laborers hailing from the western rajasthan area of modern-day india who migrated seasonally to find work, becoming trapped on the wrong side of the pakistan border when india fractured into two very different nations. within the smattering of shoddily pieced together huts before us, set amidst the monstrous sawtooth government sandstone mines, are the scant belongings and collective lives of 150 refugee families. the deliberate man walking a few steps ahead of us has dedicated his life to forming a movement aimed at fighting for the rights of this and 600 other similar communities along the india-pakistan border. this particular settlement was strategically placed in the heart of the sandstone mines, the only place that these refugees, all agriculturalists according to their caste tradition, were able to work given the restricted movement of refugees in the indian state. the work is tremendously demanding, long days under a desert sun chipping and hauling massive blocks of stone out of a quarry by hand. for those who have never known anything but the rhythmic ebb and flow of sowing, cultivating, and harvesting, it is particularly grueling, but these men and women must remain within the very limited physical area in which the government has granted them refugee status - this barren mining area outside of jodhpur, where, conveniently for government pockets, agricultural activities are not an option.
as we approach, the three men awaiting us join their flat palms together under their chins in greeting. “namaste,” we echo in muted tones, our hands joined in greeting. “come,” our host says with a flick of the hand as he begins down the path. our entourage grows quickly with bonethin white-clad men, some wearing dust streaked turbans against the scorch of the sun, already unforgiving at 10 o’clock on a february morning. a few haggard acacias provide the landscape’s only shade. wide-eyed dust smudged toddlers peek out from behind lopsided sandstone walls as we pass. we’re led down a straight dirt path to an open area where tarps and blankets have been laid out on the pebble-strewn ground. by now our group has grown to myself, my co-worker alex, our host, one of his female office associates, and about 30 refugee men. i slip out of my sandals and take a seat, cross-legged, between alex and the associate. the sun is glaring so hard in my eyes i immediately begin catching the tears rolling out of their corners. the men quickly take their seats, squeezed together facing us on the tarps, staring but not directly into my eyes; while they are clearly as interested in us as we are in them, blatant and prolonged eye contact between men and women is perceived as a provocative and dangerous gesture. i adjust my knee-length tunic over my baggy, cuff-ankled trousers, pulling the U of my sheer scarf down over my chest to be sure i project adequate conservatism, stealing stealthy glances at the creased and weary faces all around. i cast a look back over my right shoulder at the path behind us. the drop-flecked silver spheres of steel water pots lope by, balanced atop the heads of female shapes, elegantly swathed in the vibrant reds and yellows of their rajasthani saris, sheer shawls pulled down from the hair to cover their entire faces in the presence of unknown men. a couple of thigh high barefooted children totter alongside, balancing their own full mini pots on their already top-heavy frames. behind the gauzy veils, any possible interest on the women’s faces is beyond my discernment. their steady heads continue pointing directly ahead as they advance along the path toward their huts. the children gape at the foreigners seated in the heart of their territory, afterwards tottering double time to catch up with their unfaltering mothers. i turn my attention back to the gathering of stonyfaced men before me.
“accha,” (”well,”) begins our host, addressing the crowd in marwari (a language of rajasthan), greeting them all and providing what i gather is a brief summary of our organization, the foundation for sustainable development, and possibly an explanation of what we’re doing sitting on their tarp. we smile sheepishly and pretend to know what’s going on. when silence falls, i use the opportunity to awkwardly introduce myself in one of my stock hindi phrases, “namaste. mera naam lilli hai.” a few hands come together in greeting along with low scattered murmurs. marwari conversation ensues between our host and certain members of the group, the words resounding with a feeling of grievance. i continually jerk my hands in tiny, subtle motions to repel the army of flies that have descended upon us. a man approaches with a small tray, offering four glasses of water balanced atop it. i consider taking one before the memory of my experience with giardia in kenya flickers in my mind. i politely decline. our host stops the conversation with the men to ask if we have any questions for them. “how long have they been living in this settlement?” i posed quietly. he translates and answers back, “most of them have been here for about ten years.” a group of about 6 women suddenly appears at the edge of the tarp in a blinding collage of color, veils pulled lower than ever over their mysterious faces. a voice drifts out from under one of them, addressing our host. he listens before translating, “the women also want to join the group.” we all shift to make room as they arrange themselves in one corner of the tarp, segregated from the men. we’re given the opportunity to ask the women questions. my eyes skip along the veiled faces and draped saris, resting finally on a point between two laborworn bodies where a tiny dirt-streaked face peeks out from under a matted head of black hair. the toddler sinks further behind his mother when my eyes meet his. a sensation so indelible, a question so sudden. “what do they want for their children?” silence among the women for several seconds after our host translates the question. a few low murmurs and consulting between the bowed heads. finally a thin figure draped in a brilliant yellow sari in the front of the group turns to us and releases a few bold words from under the veil. our host translates: “education and employment.” he stands up, followed by a wave of group members doing the same. he motions to us to follow. “come.”
straightening our legs and replacing our shoes, we fall in step behind him and the group of men who arrange themselves about him, magnetized. it is clear that this man has the respect of this community as he listens to their hushed, urgent words, his brow knitted, nodding solemnly. our steps lead us around a crumbling sandstone wall and up a slight incline, allowing a truncated view of the stony countryside. rising out of the dust ahead are three and a half semi-walls, arranged to form a square perhaps 15 feet to a side and reaching no higher than 5 feet on any side, flat slabs of sandstone precariously balanced one atop the other, seemingly slipping apart before our eyes. gnarled branches serve as posts at several points around the square walled-in area, suspending a pitiful weathered scrap of a tarp, sagging with ripped shreds dangling down in several places. the semiopaque plastic sheet casts a ragged trapezoidal shadow over about three quarters of the 250 square feet within the makeshift walls. as we approach, the bulging eyes of 40 or more children, seated on the rocky dust floors of their learning institute, turn to meet us. standing in a sun-drenched corner of the little enclosure, a haggard-looking teacher in a well-worn emerald green sari stops speaking to examine us wearily. a few tattered posters stamped with letters and numbers cling noncommittally to the jagged walls. squeezed together in their little dustbox school, swathed in a hodgepodge of light blue cloth, an attempt at uniformity, the children stare, some smiling shyly at the foreign faces peering into their corner of existence. my heart sinks even as i catch my breath. how could something be so heartbreaking and awe-inspiring at the same time?
“up until recently, these children had no school at all,” our host explains. “it was only through intense rallying and pressure put on the local government that they were allotted a government teacher.” we come to learn that the melange of students make up grades one through five, ranging in age from about five to twelve. all sitting cross-legged, quiet, soaking up whatever knowledge they can possibly glean from the words of a single exhausted teacher. i wonder at her position, laden with the responsibility of educating these tiny wide-eyed people, born into an outcast society with the sandstone mines as their playground, this one wretched sliver of schooling their only chance of getting a step out of this hell. “the government promised to build a real school, but they haven’t,” our host says simply, walking again.
a cluster of mud-and-sandstone huts rest feebly on a rise above the classroom. two musky goats, milking bags tied around their waists, bleat irritatedly as we trod by. the group pauses in front of one tiny mud construction, windowless and about 6 feet to a side. i examine it, sweat beading on my upper lip in the heat, wondering if this little structure might be a pit latrine or a storage place. “what is this?” alex asks. “a home. a whole family sleeps in there,” our host replies. and with that, the tour continues.
back down the path, around the corners of walls and huts, a maze that grows heavier with each new piece that rises up in front of us. shuffling along with my eyes on the ground, discerning tiny 5-inch footprints impressed in the sand below, marred by the occasional splotch of water, a precious drop escaped from someone’s vessel, already mostly soaked up by the thirsty sand. on our left a water tower looms high, strangely incongruous with the impoverished setting. a thick black pipe runs down it and along the ground like a tail, stretching off into the dusty landscape as far as the eye can see. we follow alongside it for a few hundred feet before reaching a point where a small milky pool spreads from beneath it, two inexpert pipes with makeshift taps protruding abruptly from the side of the larger, sturdier parent pipe. “there is no water in this settlement. so the people have simply punctured the pipeline running into jodhpur. see,” our host indicates as a small girl steps deliberately past us, unselfconsciously skipping down the steep little embankment in a long flowing skirt, bowing down to place her steel pot below one of the meager taps. the ringing of water against metal fills all of our ears as we stand, a group of two dozen people, absurdly staring as this child completes her utterly mundane task. as the pot fills, a veiled woman with a woven grass ring atop her head joins the little girl at the tap, filling her own vessel as we continue to stare. neither seems to mind as alex takes out his camera and begins snapping.
back at our original meeting point, the tarps have been moved so that three or four people can benefit from the patchwork shade of the area’s only acacia tree. we sit. i accept a glass of hot chai. and people begin to speak.
so much to hear. so much to see on the faces of such hard, heartbroken people. one man lost seven members of his family, including a 5-year-old child, blown apart by india’s border patrol as they were fleeing across the border. another’s father died as a result of injuries inflicted by border officials as they pleaded for visas while crossing into india. one silver-bearded man became paralyzed in a mining accident and lost his wife and his livelihood in one fell blow. several men suffer from severe tuberculosis and silicosis, common for those who spend all day inhaling the fine razor powder of stone kicked up in the mines. most of these families have had to sacrifice huge sums of money to government officials at one point or another to secure a visa, renew a passport, or simply avoid a hassle. though these men are luckier than some; most of them, after a decade or more, have at last been granted indian citizenship, which allows them to access government-subsidized wheat and other staple foods. even so, they’re still ostracized as foreigners and abused as members of hinduism’s lowest caste.
these men and women are skilled. they speak the local dialect. they want to be able to do the work they’re trained to do, not slave away in government mines for a daily pittance. in a moment of excitement during our protracted discussion, several men rush to their homes to collect samples of high-quality embroidery and weaving work they and their wives have created. they want a market, but those who are lucky enough to find a middle man to buy and sell their products are exploited to the fullest, often receiving pennies for a full day’s work on a product which will eventually sell for 300 times as much. how can these creators be linked directly to a free market?
listening to their voices flying, leaning into their words, my eyes growing bigger as the ideas balloon into the atmosphere, i suddenly hit a ceiling. i feel like there’s a solution there, just there, just on the other side of…the sandstone mines. where is the market? how do we link these people, with their adroit hands and their steely wills, to the fat-pocketed consumers of the west? why are we shopping at wal-mart and supporting the large-scale destruction of ancient culture and basic human rights in china when there are literally millions of skilled people wasting away on the asian subcontinent, begging for an opportunity to work while their children sit patiently on the dirt floor of a makeshift classroom? where is the missing link to this seemingly simple chain?
i don’t know. i know virtually nothing about markets and exports and market linkages. but i know that someone knows. i’m begging for ideas. tell me your ideas. there are so many livelihood projects just waiting to take off, silk and leather and embroidery and cotton. colorful, beautiful things, but most importantly the hands and minds that create them. a huge workforce waiting for designs, eager to make whatever the west can dream in return for fair wages that won’t be snatched out of their hands by greedy middlemen. they have the ability. they just need a chance. a chance to make a life where before there was none, climb up out of these dusty hovels, out of the TB-ridden depths of the mines, up into a world where their children can sit in a real classroom and their pregnant wives will have access to healthcare, a world where water is a resource of the environment, not a precious commodity to be stealthily stolen for survival. they’re not asking for charity, not asking for money or a free ride. just a chance, a window. how can we show them that window?